top of page

Closed Comedones vs. Blackheads: Identification, difference and treatment

Writer: Quiet Alchemy
Quiet Alchemy
20 hours ago
9 min read

If your skin has tiny bumps that refuse to disappear or dark dots that make your pores look more noticeable, you might be dealing with closed comedones, blackheads, or both.

Although they are often confused, closed comedones and blackheads are two different types of comedonal acne.


Both develop when hair follicles become clogged with excess sebum, dead skin cells, and other debris. However, the way these clogged pores appear on your skin is different.


Understanding the difference matters because the ingredients and skincare approaches that help manage them can vary.


In this guide, we'll explain how to identify closed comedones and blackheads, what causes them, which skincare ingredients can help, and how to build a routine that targets both.


Closed comedones vs. blackheads showing the difference between whiteheads and open comedones.
Closed comedones vs. blackheads showing the difference between whiteheads and open comedones.

What Are Closed Comedones?


Closed comedones are small, skin-coloured or whitish bumps that develop when a hair follicle becomes clogged with oil and dead skin cells, but its opening remains closed or covered by a thin layer of skin.


They are commonly called whiteheads, although not every small white bump is necessarily a comedone.


Unlike inflamed pimples, closed comedones usually do not look red or swollen. Instead, they create a slightly uneven texture that can make your skin feel rough when you run your fingers over it.


Common Signs of Closed Comedones


  • Tiny white, cream-coloured, or skin-coloured bumps.

  • Usually non-inflamed and painless.

  • More noticeable under certain lighting.

  • Commonly appear on the forehead, chin, cheeks, and jawline.

  • Can make the skin look rough or bumpy.

  • Often difficult to remove by simply washing your face.


Closed comedones can remain for weeks or longer if the underlying pore congestion is not addressed.


If you're looking for suitable skincare products, check out our guide to the best products for closed comedones and blackheads.


Close-up of closed comedones appearing as tiny skin-coloured bumps on the forehead.
Close-up of closed comedones appearing as tiny skin-coloured bumps on the forehead.

What Are Blackheads?


Blackheads, medically known as open comedones, are another form of non-inflammatory acne.


They develop when a pore becomes clogged with sebum and dead skin cells, but unlike closed comedones, the opening remains exposed.


The dark appearance is not caused by trapped dirt. Instead, the material inside the open pore undergoes oxidation and other changes when exposed to air, resulting in its characteristic dark colour.


Blackheads are especially common on the nose, chin, and forehead.


Common Signs of Blackheads


  • Small dark brown or black dots.

  • Usually visible inside enlarged or noticeable pores.

  • Commonly appear on the nose and chin.

  • Generally non-painful and non-inflamed.

  • Can make the skin appear rough or congested.

  • May become more noticeable when excess sebum accumulates.


One important distinction: not every dark dot on your nose is a blackhead. Some may be sebaceous filaments, which are normal structures that help transport oil to the skin's surface.


If blackheads are particularly noticeable around your nose, explore our guide on how to get rid of the blackheads on your nose for practical treatment tips.


Close-up of blackheads appearing as small dark plugs inside the pores of the nose.
Close-up of blackheads appearing as small dark plugs inside the pores of the nose.

Closed Comedones vs. Blackheads: Key Differences


Although both are caused by clogged hair follicles, their appearance and structure are different.


The simplest way to remember the difference is this: closed comedones are clogged pores with a covered opening, while blackheads are clogged pores with an exposed opening.


What Causes Closed Comedones and Blackheads?


Both conditions develop through a similar process, but several factors can contribute to their formation.


1. Excess Sebum Production

Sebum is the natural oil produced by your sebaceous glands. It helps maintain your skin barrier, but excessive oil production can contribute to pore congestion.

People with naturally oily skin may be more prone to developing both closed comedones and blackheads.


2. Dead Skin Cell Accumulation

Your skin naturally sheds dead cells. However, when these cells accumulate and mix with sebum inside hair follicles, they can contribute to clogged pores.

This is one reason chemical exfoliants can be useful for managing comedonal acne.


3. Comedogenic or Heavy Skincare Products

Certain skincare and haircare formulations may contribute to clogged pores in susceptible individuals.

Heavy creams, unsuitable moisturisers, oily hair products, and poorly tolerated formulations can sometimes worsen congestion.


This does not mean every oil or moisturiser causes acne. Product formulation and individual skin response matter.


4. Hormonal Fluctuations

Hormonal changes can influence sebum production.

Androgens, for example, can stimulate sebaceous glands to produce more oil. This may contribute to comedonal acne, particularly around the chin and jawline.


5. Inadequate or Excessive Exfoliation

Not using appropriate exfoliating ingredients may allow congestion to persist.

On the other hand, aggressive scrubbing, frequent exfoliation, and harsh cleansers can irritate the skin and damage its protective barrier.


The goal is consistent, gentle skincare rather than trying to remove every clogged pore immediately.


How to Identify Whether You Have Closed Comedones or Blackheads


You can often distinguish between the two by examining their appearance and texture.


You may have closed comedones if:


  • Your skin feels bumpy even when there are no visible pimples.

  • You notice tiny skin-coloured bumps across your forehead.

  • The bumps look white under direct lighting.

  • Your skin texture appears uneven despite regular cleansing.


You may have blackheads if:


  • You notice small dark dots around your nose.

  • Your pores contain visible dark plugs.

  • Your nose looks congested even after cleansing.

  • The dark spots are individually distinguishable.


It is also possible to have both conditions simultaneously.

If the bumps are itchy, unusually uniform, inflamed, or persistent despite appropriate skincare, they may not be ordinary comedones. A dermatologist can help identify the actual cause.


Best Skincare Ingredients for Closed Comedones


Closed comedones often require ingredients that help normalise the shedding of dead skin cells and reduce pore congestion.


1. Salicylic Acid

Salicylic acid is a beta-hydroxy acid (BHA) that is oil-soluble.

It can penetrate into oil-filled pores and help loosen the buildup of dead skin cells and sebum.


It is particularly useful for people dealing with:

  • Closed comedones.

  • Blackheads.

  • Oily skin.

  • Congested pores.


Start with a low-strength leave-on formulation, such as 0.5–2%, according to product directions and your skin's tolerance.


2. Adapalene


Adapalene is a topical retinoid that helps regulate skin-cell turnover and prevent the formation of new comedones.

It is one of the better-established topical options for comedonal acne.


It can help with:

  • Persistent closed comedones.

  • Blackheads.

  • Recurrent clogged pores.

  • Comedonal acne affecting multiple areas.


It can cause dryness, peeling, and irritation initially. Introduce it gradually with appropriate moisturisation.

Avoid topical retinoids during pregnancy or when trying to conceive unless specifically advised by your healthcare professional.


3. Azelaic Acid


Azelaic acid is known for its anti-inflammatory properties and its ability to help with post-acne marks and uneven skin tone.


It may be useful when comedonal acne occurs alongside:

  • Post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation.

  • Redness.

  • Uneven skin tone.

  • Mild inflammatory acne.


However, it is not generally as effective for clearing clogged pores as a topical retinoid.


Azelaic acid can also help improve acne, post-acne marks and uneven skin tone. Learn more in our guide to the best azelaic products for hyperpigmentation.


4. Niacinamide


Niacinamide is a versatile skincare ingredient that supports the skin barrier and can help regulate the appearance of excess oil.

It may complement a routine targeting oily, congested skin.

It is not a primary treatment for established closed comedones, but it can support overall skin health.


If you're looking to add niacinamide to your skincare routine, explore our guide to the best Niacinamide serums for options that help manage excess oil and support your skin barrier.



Skincare ingredients including salicylic acid, adapalene, niacinamide and azelaic acid for managing clogged pores.
Skincare ingredients including salicylic acid, adapalene, niacinamide and azelaic acid for managing clogged pores.

Best Skincare Ingredients for Blackheads


Blackheads require a similar approach because the underlying problem is also pore congestion.


1. Salicylic Acid

Salicylic acid is particularly useful for blackheads because of its oil-soluble nature.

Regular use can help loosen the buildup inside pores and reduce the appearance of existing blackheads over time.


2. Retinoids

Retinoids such as adapalene can help prevent the formation of new comedones by regulating skin-cell turnover.

They are especially useful when blackheads keep returning despite regular cleansing and exfoliation.


3. Benzoyl Peroxide

Benzoyl peroxide is primarily used to treat inflammatory acne because it reduces acne-causing bacteria.

It is not a first-choice ingredient for isolated blackheads. If you have both comedonal and inflammatory acne, however, a dermatologist may recommend incorporating it into your routine.


4. Clay

Clay ingredients such as kaolin and bentonite can absorb excess surface oil.

They may temporarily improve the appearance of oily, congested skin, but they do not permanently remove blackheads or prevent their formation.


A Simple Skincare Routine to Manage Both


You do not need an elaborate 10-step routine to manage closed comedones and blackheads.

Consistency and choosing the right active ingredients are more important.


Morning Routine


Step 1: Gentle Cleanser

Use a mild cleanser to remove excess oil, sweat, and overnight buildup without stripping your skin.


Step 2: Niacinamide (Optional)

A niacinamide serum can complement your routine if your skin tolerates it.


Step 3: Lightweight Moisturiser

Choose a moisturiser that suits your skin type and does not leave your skin feeling excessively greasy.


Step 4: Sunscreen

Apply broad-spectrum SPF 30 or higher every morning. Sunscreen is particularly important when using exfoliating acids or retinoids.


Night Routine


Step 1: Cleanse

Remove sunscreen, makeup, and accumulated impurities using a gentle cleanser.


Step 2: Treatment

Introduce one primary pore-targeting treatment, such as salicylic acid or adapalene.

Avoid starting several active ingredients simultaneously.


Step 3: Moisturise

Finish with a barrier-supporting moisturiser to reduce dryness and irritation.


Start treatment gradually and adjust frequency according to tolerance. Combining multiple strong exfoliants and retinoids without a plan can cause irritation rather than faster results.


Morning and evening skincare routine featuring cleanser, niacinamide, moisturiser, sunscreen and acne treatments for closed comedones and blackheads.
Morning and evening skincare routine featuring cleanser, niacinamide, moisturiser, sunscreen and acne treatments for closed comedones and blackheads.

Common Mistakes That Make Closed Comedones and Blackheads Worse


Even a good skincare routine can become counterproductive if you make certain mistakes.


1. Squeezing or Picking Your Pores

Trying to squeeze out every blackhead or whitehead can irritate the surrounding skin and potentially cause inflammation, scarring, and pigmentation.

Avoid using your fingernails or sharp tools to extract clogged pores at home.


2. Overusing Salicylic Acid

Using salicylic acid too frequently can cause dryness, peeling, and irritation.

More exfoliation does not automatically mean clearer skin.


3. Using Harsh Scrubs

Physical scrubs cannot reliably clear deeper pore congestion.

Aggressive scrubbing can damage the skin barrier and make existing irritation worse.


4. Skipping Moisturiser

Oily skin still needs moisturisation.

Skipping moisturiser can make it harder to maintain a healthy skin barrier, especially when using acne treatments.


5. Expecting Overnight Results

Closed comedones and blackheads take time to improve.

Consistent treatment over several weeks is generally more realistic than expecting visible results after a few applications.


When Should You See a Dermatologist?


Occasional clogged pores can often be managed with a consistent skincare routine.


However, consider consulting a dermatologist if:

  • Closed comedones keep increasing.

  • Your bumps become painful or inflamed.

  • You develop persistent acne despite appropriate treatment.

  • Your skin develops significant irritation from active ingredients.

  • You are unsure whether the bumps are actually comedones.


A dermatologist can assess your skin and recommend appropriate treatments, including prescription retinoids or professional extraction when necessary.


Frequently Asked Questions


1. Are closed comedones the same as whiteheads?

Yes. Closed comedones are commonly called whiteheads because they appear as small white or skin-coloured bumps beneath a closed pore opening.


2. Are blackheads and closed comedones both acne?

Yes. Both are forms of comedonal acne and are generally classified as non-inflammatory acne.


3. Can closed comedones turn into blackheads?

Closed comedones and blackheads are different forms of the same basic type of pore blockage. Their appearance depends partly on whether the follicular opening is closed or exposed. They should not be thought of as necessarily progressing from one stage to another.


4. Which is harder to treat: closed comedones or blackheads?

It depends on the individual. Closed comedones can be particularly stubborn because the clogged material sits beneath a covered pore opening. Both may require consistent treatment over several weeks.


5. Does salicylic acid work for both?

Yes. Salicylic acid can help manage both closed comedones and blackheads by loosening the buildup of dead skin cells inside pores.


6. Can niacinamide remove closed comedones?

Niacinamide can support the skin barrier and help with oiliness, but it is not a primary treatment for established closed comedones. Ingredients such as salicylic acid and adapalene have stronger evidence for comedonal acne.


7. Are the tiny dots on my nose always blackheads?

No. They may be sebaceous filaments, which are normal structures that help move sebum to the skin's surface. Unlike blackheads, sebaceous filaments are usually more uniform in appearance and tend to refill naturally after removal.


8. How long does it take to get rid of closed comedones?

Improvement usually takes several weeks. Acne treatments often need around 6–12 weeks of consistent use to show meaningful results. Persistent cases may require professional treatment.


Final Thoughts


Closed comedones and blackheads may look similar at first, but understanding their differences can help you choose the right skincare approach.


Closed comedones appear as small bumps beneath the skin's surface, while blackheads are visible dark plugs inside open pores. Both are associated with excess sebum and accumulated dead skin cells.


Instead of relying on harsh scrubs, pore strips, or aggressive extraction, focus on gentle cleansing, appropriate active ingredients, moisturisation, and daily sun protection.


Clearer skin is not about using the maximum number of products. It is about understanding what your skin needs and following a routine consistently.


Comments


  • Pinterest
  • Facebook
  • Instagram

e ​

​

​

​

© 2025 by thequietalchemy

bottom of page